C64 Wishlist: Creatures III Game Concept

1 October 2020 · Updated 26 February 2026

Speculation on what a hypothetical third Creatures game for Commodore 64 might include, based on observations about the second installment’s shortcomings. The Creatures series represented Apex Computer Productions at their creative peak, making any theoretical continuation a fascinating design exercise.

Where Creatures 2 Fell Short

Missing the scrolling exploration that gave the first game its appeal. The puzzle-focused structure abandoned the platforming adventure that defined the original’s identity
Interlude sections felt laborious instead of entertaining, breaking gameplay flow with elaborate torture machine sequences that wore thin after repeated encounters
The shift toward trial-and-error puzzle solving frustrated players expecting the reflex-based platforming of the predecessor

Ideal Features for a Third Entry

Scrolling world with vertical traversal options (taking cues from Sam’s Journey), enabling exploration beyond simple left-right progression. Multiple paths through levels would encourage replay
Physics-based movement with dynamic camera behavior, creating momentum and weight that rewards skilled play while remaining accessible
Atmospheric weather systems (snow and rain affecting gameplay) with visual effects that influence traversal—slippery surfaces, reduced visibility, or altered enemy behavior
Greater arsenal diversity compared to the original’s limited weapon set, providing tactical choices beyond simply shooting everything
Enhanced visuals using high-resolution or ECM graphics modes to achieve a distinctive look that sets the game apart from its predecessors
Extended color palettes (see Luma-Driven Graphics) creating rich, vibrant environments that rival 16-bit contemporaries
Controllable transport vehicles including aircraft, expanding the scale of adventure beyond foot-based exploration
Music composed by a top-tier demoscene musician, matching the production quality of modern C64 releases with memorable themes that enhance the experience

Such a project would demand substantial development effort spanning multiple years and require licensing from the original creators or rights holders. The technical challenges alone would be significant, but the greater obstacle lies in capturing the charm and personality that made the original Creatures special.